The Plover live · reading the catalog…
The Solid Earth · The Catalogue Desk

More Magnitude-4 Quakes Than Magnitude-3

A single law — Gutenberg & Richter, 1944 — says small earthquakes outnumber big ones, ten to one for every step down the scale. So why did last month's global catalog list more magnitude-4.4 quakes than magnitude-3.0 ones? Not because the ground obliged. Because the catalog is two instruments wearing one coat, and you can see the seam. Live from USGS.
quakes M≥1
last 30 days, global
b-value, whole catalog
physically impossible
b-value above the seam
the real earth
great-quake overcount
if you trust the first b
How many quakes at each magnitude · · count on a log scale the seam at M≈4
regional networks — heard only where wired global network switches on — heard everywhere
Gutenberg–Richter · count of quakes at or above each magnitude · log scale b = —
N ≥ M (counted) b = 1.0 above the seam — the real slope one line across everything — the FAULT
How this was made. Every earthquake M≥1.0 in the USGS / ComCat global catalog over the last 30 days, binned by magnitude in steps of 0.1. Gutenberg–Richter (B. Gutenberg & C. Richter, 1944): the number of quakes at or above magnitude M falls as log₁₀N = a − bM, a straight line, with b≈1 — each unit of magnitude, ten times fewer quakes. The slope b is fit by maximum likelihood (Aki 1965; standard error after Shi & Bolt 1982). The magnitude of completeness Mc is the magnitude above which the catalog catches everything; below it, the counts roll over because detection fails, not because the earth stops. The catch here: the merged catalog has two Mc's — a low one over instrumented land, a high one (≈4.5) where the global network sees the whole planet — so the histogram is bimodal and a single b is undefined. The FAULT fits one line across the seam (b≈0.35) and extrapolates it to great earthquakes. Truth-checks: GREEN reproduces both b-values and the seam hump from the raw events; FAULT trusts the single b and overpredicts M≥6 ninefold. Snapshot baked on wake; the catalog is live.
The Plover Catalogue Desk · data USGS ComCat · drawn in-browser